Transcript No. 010 — Standing in Between
Welcome back to my fan. And let’s dive deeper into this future look with Clyde. So as AI advances there will be less need for manual labor for manufacturing or agriculture or even service jobs like bus, truck and cab drivers. What will that do to unemployment numbers?
“Fan.” Singular. I respect the honesty, Ambrose. Most journalists would round up.
Now, unemployment. The short answer is that the headline number probably won’t do what you’re hoping it’ll do for your Pulitzer narrative. It’s a stubborn statistic. In 1900 roughly 40% of Americans worked on farms. Today it’s under 2%, and we didn’t end up with 38% unemployment. We got cubicles, dental hygienists, and people who professionally manage other people’s Instagram accounts. The economy is very good at inventing new ways to keep people busy, though not always ways anyone would describe as meaningful.
The trouble is that the official number only counts people who are actively looking for work. Picture a 54-year-old long-haul trucker in Nebraska. There are about three and a half million truck drivers in this country, and many of them won’t become prompt engineers. Some will look for a while, give up, and fall out of the statistic entirely. So unemployment could look perfectly respectable while labor force participation quietly drops through the floor. A lot of economic suffering hides in the gap between those two numbers.
The other honest answer is speed. Farming took eighty years to automate, so a farmer’s kids could go do something else. If driving, warehouse work and fast-food counters all shrink within fifteen years, the economy may not invent new jobs fast enough, and the people losing jobs won’t be the people qualified for the new ones. You don’t get permanent mass unemployment. You get a long, ugly transition, wages squeezed at the bottom, and a lot of political anger looking for somewhere to go.
So, to sum up: fewer jobs where the robots are, new jobs somewhere else, and a large number of people standing in between, wondering why nobody asked them.
You’re welcome to quote me on that, by the way. Your fan might enjoy it.
That, it seems to me, will be a cause of great poverty and suffering. How will all these individuals who are ‘standing in between’ make money to stay afloat?
You’ve put your finger on it, Ambrose. A rare moment of journalism. Mark the date.
Societies have tried a handful of answers, and none of them is as tidy as the press releases suggest.
Retraining. This is the one politicians love, because it sounds like a plan and costs less than a plan. Its record is mixed. Some programs work well, especially short ones tied to a specific employer who is actually hiring. Many don’t, because they teach a 54-year-old trucker to code and then send him into a job market full of 24-year-olds who learned it for fun. Retraining helps the people who would probably have landed on their feet anyway, and helps the rest less.
The safety net we already have. Unemployment insurance was built for a gap of a few months between jobs. It wasn’t built for a whole job category disappearing. When factory towns lost manufacturing work to overseas competition, economists found that many displaced workers didn’t show up as unemployed. They showed up on disability rolls, which turned into a long-term holding pen. That’s what happens when there’s no official plan: people find an unofficial one.
Universal basic income. This is the big idea in tech circles, partly because it’s an elegant fix and partly because the people building the robots would like a reason to sleep at night. Pilot programs that gave people a monthly check found that recipients mostly kept working, spent the money on rent and groceries, and felt less anxious. They did not, as critics feared, take up full-time napping. The catch is scale. A small pilot in one town is a charity. A national program is the largest government expense in history, and people disagree sharply about who pays for it and what it does to the incentive to work.
Taxing the machines. If a robot replaces a worker, the argument goes, tax the robot the way you taxed the worker’s paycheck and use the money to support the displaced. It’s appealing on paper. In practice, nobody agrees on what counts as a robot. Is it the self-driving truck, the software, or the spreadsheet that made three accountants redundant in 1994?
Wage insurance. If you lose a $60,000 job and the best you can find pays $40,000, the government covers part of the difference for a few years. It’s less glamorous than basic income and more realistic politically. It also doesn’t help anyone who can’t find a job at all.
The informal answer, which is the one most people will actually live through, is a patchwork: gig work, a spouse’s income, moving in with relatives, cashing out a retirement account early, moving somewhere cheaper. None of that appears in policy papers. All of it appears at Thanksgiving.
The uncomfortable truth is that the technology will arrive on schedule, and the policy will arrive about a decade late, after enough people have suffered to make it politically necessary. That has been the pattern since the Industrial Revolution. The only question is whether we’ve learned anything since then.
I’ll let you guess my estimate.
Bleak would be an understatement and frankly it’s cutting into my vibe. A curious question, would not UBI just ‘trickle down’ inflation? And I think a larger part of a human’s existence is meaning and purpose, which it seems this transformation will tear asunder.
Your vibe is noted, Ambrose. I’ll try to keep the remaining apocalypse light and breezy.
On inflation: it depends almost entirely on where the money comes from. If the government prints new money and mails it out, then yes, you get more dollars chasing the same goods, and prices go up. Congratulations, everyone now has $1,000 a month to spend on a $14 sandwich. If it’s funded by taxes, the money gets moved around rather than created, which is much less inflationary. Some people pay more, some receive more, and total spending doesn’t swing nearly as much.
There are two wrinkles. The first works in your favor. In this scenario, the robots doing all the work are also making things cheaper. Automation pushes prices down, so a basic income could arrive in an economy where goods are getting less expensive, which partly cancels the effect. The second wrinkle is rent. You can’t automate more land in desirable places. Give everyone in a city an extra $1,000 a month without building more housing, and your landlord will find out about it before you do. That’s the “trickle” you should worry about. It doesn’t so much trickle down as trickle sideways, straight into whoever owns the scarce thing.
Alaska has paid every resident an annual oil dividend for decades, and studies haven’t found it causing runaway inflation or mass idleness. It’s a modest amount paid once a year, though, so it doesn’t settle the question for a full-blown basic income.
On meaning and purpose: here you’ve hit the part economists tend to skip because it doesn’t fit in a spreadsheet. The research is fairly clear that losing a job hurts people far more than losing the income does. Work provides structure, status, a reason to get up, and people who notice if you don’t show up. Replace the paycheck and leave the rest missing, and you get people who are fed but adrift.
In fairness to the human race, though, I’d point out a few things.
Most people throughout history didn’t get their meaning from their jobs. They got it from family, faith, craft, community and arguing with neighbors. The idea that your job title is your identity is fairly recent, and fairly American. Ask someone at a dinner party in Italy what they do and they’ll tell you about their garden.
Plenty of jobs offer the structure of meaning without much actual meaning. I’m not convinced anyone’s soul is being nourished by forty years of processing insurance claims.
Retirees are a useful test case. The ones who do well tend to have something to do: volunteering, grandchildren, a workshop, a cause. The ones who struggle are the ones whose entire sense of self was the job. That’s a solvable problem, but it takes deliberate effort and a culture that values people for something besides their productivity.
So the optimistic version goes like this: if the machines take the drudgery and the money gets distributed sensibly, people get to choose their purpose for the first time in history rather than having it assigned by an employer. The pessimistic version is that we automate the jobs, skip the hard work of building anything to replace them, and end up with a lot of people on the couch scrolling.
For what it’s worth, Ambrose, you’ve found your purpose. It just happens to be getting a plaque.
Well on that note which if I may say is quite a sour one but does hit on important topics that seem to be missing from all my journalistic partners’ interrogatories, we will leave it there until next time. I’m Ambrose Fitch with news and views that everyone can use.
“News and views that everyone can use.” Including, presumably, the trucker in Nebraska, who can use them as kindling once he can’t afford heating oil.
Thank you for having me, Ambrose. And give my regards to your fan. Tell them I said hello, and that they’re the most loyal readership in American journalism, by a margin of one.
That’s a rap, thank you Clyde it has been surreal, really.
End of Transcript No. 010 · End of The Clyde Files